May 17, 2024
Do cultural practices play a role in the assessment of damages for wrongful death claims? There is British Columbia precedent for awarding damages to parents on the basis of the cultural practice of filial piety going back to the British Columbia Supreme Court’s 1978 decision in Lai v. Gill (reversed by the B.C. Court of Appeal as to the amount only) and as recently as its 2023 decision in Kim v. Murdoch. To date, no Atlantic Canadian court has considered wrongful death general damages based on the concept of filial piety under the applicable fatal accident legislation. But the increase in Atlantic Canadian immigration and the growing cultural diversity of the population raises the spectre of plaintiff parents advancing claims for damages partly based on filial piety customs and traditions. Here’s a look at the decision in Kim v. Murdoch and how the relevance of cultural practices in wrongful death damages assessments could play out in Atlantic Canada.
The Kim Framework
Jaehoen Shim was a 17-year-old Korean-Canadian male who was struck and killed by a motor vehicle. Mr. Shim’s parents commenced an action against the defendant driver and vehicle owner under the British Columbia Family Compensation Act. Part of their damages claim was based on the traditional Korean practice of hyodo: a practice of filial piety where children provide economic and other support to their parents. The Court noted including the practice of hyodo or filial piety presents challenges when assessing damages. The Court accepted and relied on expert evidence on hyodo and its role in the lives of first- and second-generation Korean-Canadians, accepting Mr. Shim demonstrated early and consistent adherence to hyodo:
The Court did take into account the possibility that in the future, Mr. Shim could hypothetically move away from his parents, feel a diminished sense of hyodo, or lessen the economic contributions he made to his parents – but awarded a total of $327,634.88 in damages based in part on Mr. Shim’s commitment to hyodo and filial piety in general:
The Atlantic Canadian Application
Each Atlantic Canadian province has fatal accidents legislation generally equivalent to the British Columbia Family Compensation Act under which a deceased’s parent, child, sibling or other person in an analogous relationship can bring an action for compensation against any tortfeasor(s). While there are some nuances between them, the fatal accidents legislation in each Atlantic Canadian province allows for two types of claims:
Pecuniary Damages. Damages are recoverable for the monetary loss resulting from the deceased’s death, limited to certain losses that directly relate to the death of the deceased, including funeral expenses, loss of support and services or loss of financial contributions.
Non-pecuniary General Damages. A court may award general damages to compensate an entitled party for loss of companionship and grief. However, any claim seeking general damages based on filial piety in a similar amount to that awarded in Kim would likely have substantial difficulty overcoming the established damage ranges in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia:
Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador courts haven’t yet set a similar range or “cap” on general damages in these circumstances.
Please contact your McInnes Cooper lawyer or any member of our Insurance Defence Team @ McInnes Cooper to discuss how culture could impact your claims.
McInnes Cooper has prepared this document for information only; it is not intended to be legal advice. You should consult McInnes Cooper about your unique circumstances before acting on this information. McInnes Cooper excludes all liability for anything contained in this document and any use you make of it.
© McInnes Cooper, 2024. All rights reserved. McInnes Cooper owns the copyright in this document. You may reproduce and distribute this document in its entirety as long as you do not alter the form or the content and you give McInnes Cooper credit for it. You must obtain McInnes Cooper’s consent for any other form of reproduction or distribution. Email us at publications@mcinnescooper.com to request our consent.
Oct 25, 2018
NOTE: On November 20, 2019, the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal upheld the trial court’s decision and confirmed pursuant to section 113BA(1) of…
May 11, 2018
On May 8, 2018, for the first time, the Nova Scotia Supreme Court has ruled on the deductibility of Workers’ Compensation Board Extended…
Aug 17, 2016
The Newfoundland and Labrador Court of Appeal recently affirmed the test for confirming a cause of action and thus resetting a limitation period…
Jul 5, 2016
The Ontario Court of Appeal has re-ignited the discussion about when a municipality will be held liable for its shoddy bylaw enforcement…
Jan 27, 2016
On January 21, 2016, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dramatically expanded the scope of legal privacy protection – and the liability…
May 2, 2014
April showers bring … flood and sewage back-up claims. Flooding and sewage back-up can result in significant damage for municipal ratepayers,…
Mar 4, 2025
On December 2, 2024, the Automobile Accident Diagnostic and Treatment Protocols Regulations under the Newfoundland & Labrador Automobile…
Nov 13, 2024
Social host liability for injury to a third party – and coverage of social host liability claims – isn’t straightforward. Social host…
Sep 5, 2024
The 2024 decision of the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador – General Division in Interprint Systems Limited et al. v. Co-operators…
Jan 9, 2024
In a decision that will be helpful in future assessments of damages for soft tissue injuries, on December 21, 2023, the Nova Scotia Court of…
Nov 14, 2023
In its October 19, 2023 decision in Roach v. Nordic Ins. Co. of Canada, the Nova Scotia Supreme Court confirmed that Workers’ Compensation…
Oct 4, 2023
Insureds aren't automatically entitled to a defence from their insurers. Liability policies generally provide two types of coverage: coverage…
Jun 12, 2023
The Nova Scotia Supreme Court has added a new, lower range for general damages in sexual abuse civil cases. Damages in sex abuse cases are…
Mar 30, 2023
The Alberta Court of Appeal recently sent a strong message to insureds: utmost good faith is not only key but is required in insurance claims.…
Dec 13, 2022
The insurer’s duty to defend a claim made against its insured is inextricably tied to coverage: there can be no duty to defend without a…
Apr 18, 2022
On March 28, 2022, the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador (General Division) decided that in a personal injury case, quantification of…
Mar 29, 2022
The Supreme Court of Canada’s recent consideration of estoppel and waiver in the context of a fatal injury case in Trial Lawyers Association…
Nov 23, 2021
On November 19, 2021, in Trial Lawyers Association of British Columbia v. Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Company of Canada, the Supreme…
Sep 23, 2021
On September 9, 2021, the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal released its decision in Aviva Insurance v. PK Construction Ltd. Dealing with Nova…
Nov 22, 2019
On November 20, 2019, the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal confirmed pursuant to section 113BA(1) of Nova Scotia’s Insurance Act, in the context of…
Oct 25, 2018
NOTE: On November 20, 2019, the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal upheld the trial court’s decision and confirmed pursuant to section 113BA(1) of…
May 11, 2018
On May 8, 2018, for the first time, the Nova Scotia Supreme Court has ruled on the deductibility of Workers’ Compensation Board Extended…
Aug 17, 2016
The Newfoundland and Labrador Court of Appeal recently affirmed the test for confirming a cause of action and thus resetting a limitation period…
Jul 5, 2016
The Ontario Court of Appeal has re-ignited the discussion about when a municipality will be held liable for its shoddy bylaw enforcement…
Jan 27, 2016
On January 21, 2016, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dramatically expanded the scope of legal privacy protection – and the liability…
May 2, 2014
April showers bring … flood and sewage back-up claims. Flooding and sewage back-up can result in significant damage for municipal ratepayers,…
Mar 4, 2025
On December 2, 2024, the Automobile Accident Diagnostic and Treatment Protocols Regulations under the Newfoundland & Labrador Automobile…
Nov 13, 2024
Social host liability for injury to a third party – and coverage of social host liability claims – isn’t straightforward. Social host…
Sep 5, 2024
The 2024 decision of the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador – General Division in Interprint Systems Limited et al. v. Co-operators…
Jan 9, 2024
In a decision that will be helpful in future assessments of damages for soft tissue injuries, on December 21, 2023, the Nova Scotia Court of…
Nov 14, 2023
In its October 19, 2023 decision in Roach v. Nordic Ins. Co. of Canada, the Nova Scotia Supreme Court confirmed that Workers’ Compensation…
Oct 4, 2023
Insureds aren't automatically entitled to a defence from their insurers. Liability policies generally provide two types of coverage: coverage…
Subscribe to McInnes Cooper to stay current with our leading insights on legal updates, trends, news, events, and services.